I have both. And both have their uses. Early waterfowl season (October/November) I love utilizing the duck boat. Later when it gets cold and the big northern birds come down, the airboat gets me into better areas to get to higher quality birds. And especially after the ice gets here, the airboat is the ticket. The mud boat is substantially cheaper to run, I can hunt right out of the boat, I can take newbies out in the duck boat easier than the airboat,, its just less of a production with the duck boat. but the duck boat needs a fair amount of water. the airboat needs nothing but fuel. the airboat is more fun to drive but costs a lot more. its a trade off. my suggestion, get both.